Toilet Keeps Running? Fix the Five Usual Suspects
A toilet that keeps running is wasting real money: even a moderate leak sends 200+ gallons a day down the drain, and a wide-open one can triple a water bill. The good news is the cause is almost always one of five inexpensive parts in the tank, and ten minutes with the lid off identifies which.
Describe the symptom to a pro
A local licensed plumber can usually tell you over the phone whether it needs a visit.
(855) 000-0000New installs, replacements & repairs · No obligation
Safety first: if you smell gas, see water near electrical outlets or your panel, or sewage is contacting living areas, get people clear first. For a gas smell, leave and call 911 or your gas utility's emergency line before anything on this page.
- !Water on the floor around the toilet, not just running inside the tank (different problem, act fast)
- !The supply line or its connection at the wall is leaking or spraying
- !The shutoff valve at the wall will not turn and water is overflowing the bowl
- !A visible crack in the tank that is weeping water
- !Sewage smell or water backing up into the bowl from below (that is a drain problem, not a tank problem)
- ✓Lift the tank lid and look: is water spilling into the overflow tube (fill problem), or is the flapper at the bottom not sealing (flush valve problem)?
- ✓Do the dye test: a few drops of food coloring in the tank, wait 15 minutes without flushing. Color in the bowl means the flapper is leaking
- ✓Press down gently on the flapper with a stick: if the running stops, the flapper or its seat is your culprit
- ✓Check the chain: too tight holds the flapper open a crack, too loose gets trapped under it. One link of slack is right
- ✓Adjust the float: bend the arm or turn the adjustment screw so the water line sits about an inch below the top of the overflow tube
- →You replaced the flapper and the fill valve and it still runs: the flush valve seat itself is worn or pitted, which means draining and unbolting the tank
- →The shutoff valve at the wall is seized, corroded or weeping: replacing an angle stop is quick for a plumber and not a great first solo project
- →More than one toilet in the house runs or hisses: that pattern points at high house pressure or a failing pressure regulator, not coincidence
- →The toilet is also rocking, leaking at the base, or over 25 years old: one visit can fix the running and price a replacement against repeated repairs
- →Phantom flushing at night (tank refills on its own): a slow flapper leak you have confirmed but cannot stop with a new flapper
Not sure what you are looking at? Just ask.
Calls are answered around the clock and routed to a licensed plumbing pro serving your area.
Call & describe the job
Tell us what you need: a new install, a replacement, or something that started leaking.
Get matched on the line
You are connected with a local licensed plumbing pro who serves your area.
Compare your numbers
Use the ranges on this page to sanity-check the quote before you commit.
The five parts, in order of likelihood
The flapper is the rubber seal at the bottom of the tank that lifts when you flush, and it is the cause of most running toilets. Rubber hardens, warps and grows a mineral skin; chlorine tank tablets accelerate all three. Symptoms: the dye test bleeds color into the bowl, or the toilet refills briefly on its own every so often (the "phantom flush"). The part costs $5 – $15 and swaps without tools.
The fill valve is the tower on the left that refills the tank. When it fails to shut off fully, water keeps trickling and the tank hisses long after the flush. Worn seals inside the valve or debris from the supply line are typical; modern replacements cost $10 – $25 and install with one nut under the tank.
The float tells the fill valve when to stop. Set too high, water pours into the overflow tube forever, which is the classic always-running tank. Adjustment costs nothing: a screw on the valve or a gentle bend of the arm drops the waterline to an inch below the overflow tube.
The chain seems too small to matter until it does: too short and the flapper never seats, too long and the slack tucks under the flapper edge. One link of play with the flapper closed is the spec.
The flush valve seat is the brass or plastic ring the flapper seals against. Decades of mineral buildup pit the surface, and at that point new flappers stop helping. The repair means draining the tank and unbolting it from the bowl: still a modest job, but the one where most homeowners hand it over.
What the water is costing you while you decide
Running toilets are silent budget leaks because the water meter is the only witness. A moderate flapper leak wastes 200 – 400 gallons a day; a fill valve stuck open with water topping the overflow tube can pass several thousand. At typical U.S. water and sewer rates of $8 – $15 per thousand gallons, a bad month with one running toilet adds $50 – $200 to the bill, which is why utilities flag the pattern on smart meters.
The quick containment move while you wait for parts or a pro: close the shutoff valve at the wall behind the toilet (clockwise), and open it only to refill before use. If that valve will not turn, that is itself worth fixing during the same visit.
What a plumber visit costs for this
A running toilet is usually a service-call-priced fix: $100 – $275 nationally for diagnosis plus a flapper, fill valve or float repair completed on the spot. A full tank rebuild (flapper, fill valve, flush valve and supply line, the right call on a toilet you otherwise like) runs $200 – $400. Replacing a corroded shutoff angle stop adds $75 – $150 when done during the same visit.
If the flush valve seat is shot on an older toilet, weigh the rebuild against replacement: a new mid-grade toilet installed typically runs $375 – $800, flushes better than a 1990s unit ever did, and resets every wear part to zero. A pro can price both paths in one conversation, and the running-water habit of older fill valves is also a pressure clue worth mentioning if your relief valves drip too.
Fix it once: the 10-minute rebuild logic
Tank parts age together. If the flapper failed at year 8, the fill valve is the same age, made of the same rubber and plastic, sitting in the same chlorinated water. Replacing parts one failure at a time means three small annoyances over two years; a $30 – $45 combo kit (flapper plus fill valve) resets the whole tank in one session and is the standard pro move.
Two habits keep the new parts alive: skip in-tank chlorine tablets (they cook rubber parts and void some flapper warranties; bowl-side cleaners are fine), and exercise the wall shutoff valve a quarter turn once or twice a year so it never seizes into place exactly when you need it.
Ready to get it handled?
One call, no obligation. Describe the job and compare the quote against the ranges above.